Face it—Your great CD Collection Ripping Project is never going to end!

This afternoon was kind of lazy and rainy, and I found myself sifting through stacks of CD cases again, full of enthusiasm as I discovered some lost Rolling Stones and David Bowie albums, imagining how few discs remained before I could declare victory. But then I stumbled across a huge cache of classical music discs which immediately dampened my spirits, because these are usually the kind that come up as “Unknown Disc/Unknown Artist” when you try to download the titles. And there were loads of them.

Here are a few thoughts I have to share on these great media library projects. Not only are they never-ending, but the longevity of the task should guide some key decisions you make as you plod along.

Accept that it’s Never Going to End

I currently have ongoing projects to scan in every scrap of paper in my house, rip every CD to MP3, and scan in every pre-digital-era photograph. But the corpus is just too large. And I haven’t even considered ripping video; I have accepted that a full digital video library is a little too ambitious for me these days.

We need to be aware of this from the very beginning; if you feel like you bit off more than you can chew, you are normal.

Never Give Up

Try to keep your goals clear, so that you don’t lose steam and give up. Perhaps you are looking forward to being able to place the plastic boxes all in storage. Perhaps you can’t wait to be able to make those uber party mixes from your rich collection. In any case, every hour you spend doing the drudgery of ripping CDs brings you a little closer to these goals.

Prioritize Your Work

It is a whole lot better to spend your first days ripping your favorite music to MP3 than to be ripping some weird CDs your roommate left behind in college. Today I happily skipped over the Talking Heads CDs that I inherited from my brother—those don’t really need to be in my iTunes library, do they?

Keep it Simple

Make your work flow as simple as possible. You may still be doing this in three years—don’t over complicate things.

I have been working on my own collection for the past three years. When I first started, I was ripping the music on a PC using a tool called cdex to rip the MP3s and another tool called Mp3tag to edit the tags. These days I use iTunes on my Mac to do both of these tasks. If I had some really fancy work flow going, it might not have been so easy to change machines. By keeping things simple, I was able to do exactly the same thing today that I did three years ago.

Choose Good Settings

…for your software. You don’t want to have to do this again, do you? And don’t go cheap on the bit rate, if you have the space.

In addition, you will probably want to decide between the convenience of a universal format versus the power of a proprietary or niche format. In my example, I opted to use MP3 for all of my music instead of some of the other, more powerful, formats available. I was stung once by the switch from PC to Mac where the handful of CDs that I had ripped to .wmf files were no longer usable.

If you are ripping everything to some killer lossless format, be sure you are looking far down the road and considering compatibility issues.

Back it up!

Make sure your backup process is ready for the increased load. If your backups consist of burning DVDs (or worse, CDs) of your data, you will very quickly tire of this, and you may just abandon one of the most important parts of your work flow. Oh, and remember, if there aren’t two copies in separate places, it isn’t a backup.

A couple of months ago I bought two of those nice pocket-size portable hard drives, and I always leave one at the office and I swap them once per week. This works for me: they are 320GB hard drives, providing plenty of room for all of my thousands of scanned documents, tens of thousands of photographs, and many thousands of MP3s, with plenty of elbow room.

When ripping a CD collection, the data risk is lower since you still retain the original CDs, but it still is a lot of work to rip them all. Don’t overlook the backup, or you will cry when the hard drive crashes.

Know Where You Have Been

Come up with a simple “bread crumb” mechanism to know where you have already been. You want to be able to quickly identify the music CDs you already ripped, without having to bring up iTunes every time. Keep the three year horizon in mind, so you choose a technique that will not be mysterious to you after some time passes (Hmmmm…. did I dog ear the corner of the CD insert to mark it? Where did I put that notebook where I wrote them down?)

I chose simplicity: I have one of those nice metallic Sharpie markers, the silvery kind. I put a small dot on the hub of each CD after I ripped it, just above the center hole. This way, several years from now, I should easily be able to spot the CDs that haven’t been introduced to my digital library.

I do this with photographs as well. As I scan them, I put a small marker dot on the back of each photograph, in the corner.

Finally, Enjoy Your Music!

I am quite capable of getting all wrapped up in the process for the sake of the process. Don’t forget to actually listen to the music you ripped!